The tariff barriers are gradually melting away, and the operation of the Hainan Free Trade Port is not only about duty-free shopping, but also a profound transformation aimed at the regional economic pattern.
"Small nations like Singapore must remain highly alert, as our negotiation space is extremely limited." This was the statement of Singapore's Prime Minister Lawrence Wong at an internal meeting before Hainan's customs closure. With the official launch of Hainan's full island customs closure on December 18, this Singaporean leader unexpectedly announced a vacation until 2026, sparking widespread speculation.
Hainan's customs closure may seem like just an economic policy adjustment for an island, but the strategic layout behind it directly targets Singapore's economic lifeline of transshipment trade that has lasted for a century. As Hainan introduces lower tax rates and higher customs clearance efficiency than Singapore, we are witnessing a reshaping of the regional economic landscape.
01 Policy sword: How Hainan accurately strikes at Singapore's lifeline
The core of Hainan's customs closure operation lies in the innovative regulatory model of "opening the first line, controlling the second line, and allowing freedom within the island." In simple terms, this means turning the entire Hainan Island into a huge special customs supervision area.
Compared to Singapore, Hainan's tax policy is more attractive. Hainan implements a dual cap tax rate of 15% for both corporate income tax and personal income tax, which is 2 percentage points lower than Singapore's corporate income tax.
Moreover, Hainan levies personal income tax on individuals residing for more than 183 days only at progressive rates of 3%, 10%, and 15%, with high-end talent exempt from tax on amounts exceeding 15%.
In terms of customs efficiency, Hainan's "seamless customs clearance" model allows goods to complete inspection and release in as little as 2 minutes, simplifying the declaration data from 105 items to 33 items, reducing inspection time by 88%. This efficiency has surpassed Singapore and has become a key factor in attracting international trade.
Hainan's value-added processing policy is even more powerful: foreign raw materials can enter the inland market tax-free after processing and adding value in Hainan by more than 30%. This policy directly shakes the position of Singapore as a transshipment processing base, prompting companies to begin re-planning their supply chain layout.
02 Data speaks: The trade pattern is quietly changing
The numbers are the most powerful proof. In the first 10 months of 2024, Hainan's imports and exports with ASEAN reached 48.29 billion yuan, a year-on-year increase of 66.5%, with a growth rate exceeding Hainan's foreign trade growth rate by 45.3 percentage points during the same period.
ASEAN has maintained its position as Hainan's largest trading partner for three consecutive years, accounting for 32% of Hainan's total foreign trade.
Even more surprising are the trade changes with specific countries: Hainan's imports and exports with Indonesia have surpassed 10 billion yuan, while exports to Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, and Laos have multiplied. These increases do not come from nowhere; they correspond directly to the loss of Singapore's transshipment trade.
Indonesian cargo ships save 6 days of sailing time and 15% in fuel costs by sailing directly to Hainan instead of going through Singapore, with an average savings of about $600 per container. Hainan's bonded fuel prices are 15% lower than those in Singapore, and warehouse rents are only one-fifth of those in Singapore.
These data confirm Huang Xuncai's concerns: Singapore's transshipment function is being gradually replaced by Hainan.
03 Industrial impact: From logistics channels to value creation
Hainan's customs closure is not just about the flow of goods, but also about the reshaping of industrial value chains. Manufacturing in Singapore accounts for about 20% of GDP, of which the semiconductor manufacturing sector accounts for 30.7% of total manufacturing output. Hainan's value-added processing policy is attracting high-end manufacturing to shift to Hainan.
A typical case is that Hainan's refining industry has successfully established a process for importing propane with a 30% value-added and zero tariff, cumulatively reducing raw material procurement costs by 8.5 million yuan. This cost advantage poses direct competitive pressure on Singapore's precision manufacturing, aviation maintenance, and other industries.
Hainan's four leading industries—tourism, modern services, high-tech industries, and tropical characteristic efficient agriculture—account for 67.2% of GDP, and it is expected to rise to around 70% by 2027. This clear industrial planning contrasts sharply with Singapore's relatively singular economic structure.
In the financial sector, Hainan has launched a multi-functional free trade account, reducing the cross-border settlement time from 1-2 days to 2 hours. Although Singapore still holds an advantage in financial maturity, Hainan's speed of catching up is remarkable.
04 Singapore's response: From anxiety to transformation
In the face of Hainan's rise, Singapore is not sitting idle. Singapore is accelerating its layout in high-value-added industries such as legal arbitration, offshore finance, and green finance. They are trying to maintain the advantage of high-end services by establishing an international arbitration center and a carbon trading center.
At the same time, Singapore is also seeking regional cooperation, collaborating with Malaysia and Indonesia to build the "Malacca Strait Economic Cooperation Zone," hoping to maintain its influence in the region through joint port operations.
Interestingly, Singapore Port Authority has signed a memorandum of cooperation with Yangpu to explore the model of "Hainan transshipment + Singapore services." This indicates that Singapore realizes the trend is irreversible and is trying to share in the development of Hainan.
However, in the long run, as China's institutional innovations continue to improve and Hainan makes progress in building a soft environment in areas like law and finance, Singapore's existing advantages will gradually diminish. When Hainan's industrial ecosystem is fully mature, the challenges faced by Singapore will become even more severe.
05 Future pattern: Reconstruction of regional economic order
Based on VAR time series model analysis, the economic impact of Hainan's customs closure on Singapore will show a three-stage development: 2026-2027 will be the initial impact stage, with Singapore's transshipment trade volume expected to decline by 10-15%; 2028-2030 will be the structural adjustment stage, with Singapore accelerating its transition to high-end services; and after 2030, it will enter a new balance stage, forming a differentiated division of labor pattern between Hainan and Singapore.
Hainan's customs closure represents the emergence of a new model: the trade center is shifting from a purely geographical hub to a comprehensive hub supported by a vast market and industry. Singapore's traditional model of collecting "tolls" based on its geographic location appears inadequate in the face of deep integration of industrial chains.
Hainan is backed by a super-sized consumer market of 1.4 billion people, which is an advantage that Singapore cannot compare to. Goods arriving in Singapore are often just transiting; but when they arrive in Hainan, they can either be transiting or be the final destination for direct sales.
This fundamental difference determines the direction of the future reshaping of the regional economic landscape.
With the implementation of Hainan's customs closure policy, the international shipping capacity of Yangpu Port has exceeded 7 million deadweight tons, and the bonded fuel refueling volume soared by 210% in the first three quarters, of which 30% comes from ships that originally docked in Singapore. Shipping companies are not foolish; they will go where it is cheaper and more efficient.
Singapore's Changi Airport is still busy, and vessels in the Malacca Strait continue to flow, but changes have quietly occurred. Hainan's customs closure is not just an adjustment of economic policy, but also a barometer for the restructuring of global trade patterns.
In the next decade, we will see more Southeast Asian goods directly connecting with Hainan, more multinational companies setting up regional headquarters in Hainan, and more international capital entering the Chinese market through Hainan. This transformation has just begun, and its impact will far exceed our imagination.
Follow me@崎哥说币 #加密市场观察 $BTC
